MOE vs Teachers Part 3 of 3
13 JUL 07

Before this article turns into one bad long-winded Masters of the Sea type of soap opera, I will suggest some solutions to clear whatever djinns that may be lurking in the depths of this steaming pile of red tape crap that have rendered numerous teachers retarded. Let us deal with discipline!

Teachers spend their time not just teaching but also with discipline. Somebody have to tell the boy to stop running in the nude in class right? And this can take from mere 3 minutes to a whopping 35- one whole lesson period. The discipline situation is so bad in some schools that police officers have to be called in to clear the matter. Police officers are suppose to nab criminals NOT naughty children so again this is a waste of crucial resources and indirectly a waste of tax payers money. So to release the burden of discipline from teachers you have to form a committee solely dedicated for discipline.

That means if a student get beyond the limits and mimics a wild beast, teachers can press the red button, pull a plug, yank a chain, scratch a wall, whatever, to alert this discipline committee to nab the animal student and tell him to write a reflection… Reflection? Hahah please don’t humor me.. I’m the one in charge of the humor oh, policy maker man. What is there to reflect also I don’t know. You are rude to your teacher and your parents did not instill you with sufficient manners, the committee is there to straighten things out by sheer fear. Yup, that’s right. Fear works fast and fear works very well. And I have seen it first hand. The students where I was teaching have this logistics uncle and every wild wolf student became an innocent puppy as soon as this uncle walks by. Why?
Because this uncle was an RSM in the past. (RSM is an officer in the military incharge of discipline in a camp.. For short, he’s job is to give hell to the trouble makers.) Since he has tonnes of experience in the army, every menacing grimace is executed to perfection. He doesn’t speak, he thunders. Honestly, I was petrified of him too and about to give him 20 push ups whenever we made eye contact. But most importantly, everybody behaved.

Now imagine if you have 4 RSM-like people in charge of discipline in a whole school. They can deal with light to serious cases. Their job is to deal with discipline and nothing else. Have a 2 man 2 woman team. Play bad cop, good cop with the kids. Give stern warning to nerds and do CID style of interrogation for those crazy ones who have gangster links. Crack down on bullies in school. And their presence alone could send a strong signal to the kids. They should not mingle and be cracking jokes with the kids like some Santa Claus; they should smile sparingly and have a serious demeanor at all times. This committee also works after school, patrolling neighborhoods to nab loitering students under void decks and even visiting parents of delinquents. No teacher has time for that sort of commitment because they are eyeballs deep with teacher responsibilities. If properly executed, teachers’ stress levels would decrease because they know they have a full-time discipline team backing them up and even students would know where to go if they are confronted with bullies.


Are you sure you want to mess with them?
I draw them, I scared already.
So now you have a super discipline force dealing those terrible students. Teachers don’t have to deal with them anymore. Now, comes a student who just does not want to learn. A veteran teacher has told me that the Government have this policy where a student have to receive “compulsory primary and secondary school education”. I do not agree to this because I find this impractical. You can only bring the sheep to the river but its up to the sheep to drink from it.

Likewise, you cannot force a kid to study if he does not want to. I have seen some this troublemaker student slept throughout the whole 2 hours of examination time and he did not bother to even write his name. Even when I told him to wake up, he did it half assed and falls back to slumber again. Why is this kid in school? He is better joining the workforce if that is what he wants. So I totally support expulsion for kids who have severe discipline problems because they are wasting resources, they disrupt lessons with their antics, and it also acts as a wake up call for them.
I know of a student who quit school and after he found out how tough it is in the working world, he came back after a year and cause no trouble in class whatsoever. But if you wanna expel students left and right you MUST have a clear way for them to come back to school if they want to. Polytechnics in Singapore should be open to the public like how community college in the US works. Classes in US colleges have students in their 30s sitting side by side with 19-year-olds. That’s how they should be because if one day these trouble makers suddenly wake up and wanna go back to school and learn a skill, they can do so and they know how.

I know I have mentioned this point before in my “Our Education System” article but I have to hilight it again. The secondary school timetable is one bad rush hour. Teachers are running here and there like a headless chicken. The 1 period is a joke because you cannot teach anything in 35 minutes because you fail to consider “settling down time.” If I teach my Cartoon art classes in 35 minutes, parents would be asking for a refund. And on top of that, teachers have to organize CCA, Speech Day, Youth Day, Sports Day, Angkat Principal Day etc. come on man, something got to give. I strongly suggest stretching school hours not to pressure the students more… but to provide a much more comfortable pace. Teachers want to TEACH, they are not your punching bag for students, parents, principal and MOE. And for crying out loud, can you scrap streaming already?!


MOE: Gives a right jab by placing ridiculous education policies.
Principal: Delivers an uppercut by not backing teachers up when a complaint arise.
Student: A left hook by giving teachers hell and he knows how to use the "Parents" card.
Parent: A punch in the groin by having that I'm-right-all-the-time -because-I'm-the-parent mentality.
One final point is about the 30k bond that teachers have to sign. The working policies in Singapore have always placed the employees dead LAST. Check this out: Aspiring teachers to-be goes to NIE for teacher course > After that they have to sign a bond of 3 years. You will be posted to a school. The first year is crucial because that is when you get “confirmed”. If you do not get “confirmed” after 1 year, you are forced to break your bond and fork out $30,000 to pay MOE. Yup the zeroes are all there. It gets worse. Who confirms you? The principal. What happens if the principal doesn’t like your face and play politics? You are DOOMED! A teacher friend suggests that MOE should place the aspiring teacher under probation first before signing on the dotted line. To me, there’s a lot of options MOE can take without ruining people lives financially and psychologically.

So to summarize, MOE are driving teachers insane because:

1) They slow teachers down with super long meetings when teachers already have tonnes of work to do.

2) They have this parent’s first policy and practically tremble at EVERY complaint from parents.

3) They have an unfair bondage policy where the aspiring teacher has to pay $30k if he/she does not get confirmed.

4) Because of the lack of foresight and even when they know deep down streaming is a failure but they have this too big of an ego to admit their mistake and change their policies, the current system clump all the students with discipline problems into one class, making them a nightmare to teach and thus driving stress levels high.

Agree or Disagree? Barrage me with emails! I’ll post noteworthy ones if I get any.

Teachers play a very important role because they are the forefront in shaping our youths. They are like secondary parents and they do more than just teach. Before I end this article about teachers once and for all.. I would like to ask teachers to share with me your horror teaching stories! Stay anonymous if you want to but do share!

“How can you have children when you have no wife?”
“How can you expect change, when you do nothing?”

Ponder on that!
Evil Bunny!


Tsk. tsk. if you have this mental attitude,
you should be ashamed of yourself.
 
  Over-protective parents and spoilt kids
Sick And Tired:

i find that i have to agree with your article about the teachers part2. the administration nowadays protect the young so much that they are spitting back the hardwork and care that the older generation have been giving. ets be straight here, i was not a bad kid in school but neither
was i a good one. we all have gone through all the turbulent years in secondary school and would have been involved one way or another in a fight or something with the teachers. who wasn't rebellious during those days?

but the kids nowadays are not respectful at all of the teachers and what they have done for them. trust me, i have done a few tuitioning before and this coming from a fellow teacher who i believed was having quite a tough time in school struck a chord in me.

how can parents nowadays be so protective of their kids? i was surprised to see a pri one student, with his uniform on, playing with his psp and his *coughs* girl was sitting beside him in the bus. What the f$#@?!?! i didn't remember whether i was even thinking of having a gurl at that age!

whats more, because of the globalisation and the widespread powers of the internet, porn, violence and all the other BS are coming through so fast that you don't even realise that your beloved son / daughter are exposed to it. it does and you better watch out for it lest it makes your beloved son / daughter the gremlin he /she is.

i do not abhor change, or progress or parents protecting their young ones. that i noe is the basic human neccesity and capacity of growth and safety. in fact, i welcome the growth that our country has done, but just like the administration in the highest level of governance, parents put on a cloak over their child thinking that it is preventing the child from facing all the crisis that the parents had faced. but do they check on the child? i think not.

they blame the world world including themselves except their offspring. just look at the incident in the bus. oh i tell you, if i was in that bus, seeing that idiot of a JC student punching the driver, i would have tackled him a la Goldberg, punch his face and throw him out of the bus kicking his ass! a freaking JC student!! like what the F@%$! and what does the dad do, begging forgiveness on behalf of the kid. i can't believe such stupidity exist in Singapore. and we are what, a first world country? (or did i get that wrong?)

heck, if i was you when that Sec 3 kid mocked you, i would have said out loud, "what stare stare? you think its funny right?" and promptly bring him to say what he did at the school PA system and let everyone know what an idiot he was.

anyway, hope you do put this up. i'm sick and tired of whiny kids and whiny parents.

  Evil Bunny:
Yup, Parents being overprotective with their kids is one thing but schools actually entertaining over-protective parents is another. Bottomline is: If your kid does not have adequate discipline because of your failure as a parent, it is up to the school to take on the responsibilty to instill some discipline.
  Hated being in bond-age
Road Runner:
I was trained in NIE and when i graduated, i was posted to this school. And it was a nightmare right from day one. Now, all teachers, upon entering NIE, had to sign the bond for 3 years. depending on the course that you go to, but usually its 3 years.

the first year is the most crucial year as that is the year when you get CONFIRMED. if you don't get confirmation from the school (in which case, its endorsed by the PRINCIPAL) within a year, you would be reviewed again of your performance before that year ends and you would be given the choice to either stay for another six months and get yourself confirmed, or u can request to go to another school and get yourself confirmed. Now what happens if the school refuses to confirm you? YOU WOULD BE FORCED TO QUIT AND PAY BACK THE BOND. and that is over SGD$30,000. So why the heck did they make u sign the bond first before the confirmation period? if you are not sure whether your employee will perform, then put him under probation but do not bond him. That is a lose-lose situation for him/her. Which is not fair. The bond thing is VERY UNFAIR AND IS NOT BENEFICIAL TO THE EMPLOYEE. What is the purpose of training your employees if you have no intention of retaining them? Stupid right?

And of course, your confirmation is subject to how you suck up to your HODs and Principals. The politics is one aspect which i was not prepared to face when i joined the school. My HOD does not like me, cause i had trouble keeping up with the amount of work that was given back then. AND I DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO PLAY POLITICS. For me, i will not suck up to anyone, even if it earns me a few hundred dollars more. I will just do my job, whether you like it or not. Can you imagine, i had to prepare lessons every week (lesson plans to be handed in every friday) for 8 classes and mark (basic job). Then, the department gave me extra work like handling departmental duties like planning and executing programs for some school events in which i have to hold quizzes for the whole school, train MCs, prepare quiz questions, train kids for public speaking skills and making announcements every morning. On top of that, i have CCA in which i have to plan for activities. PLUS i have classroom observations every month in which i have to prepare for and this is the main determinant of my confirmation status. I also had to attend courses every now and then and even on sundays, have to bring students for some stupid field trip. And i have to carry out remedials and extra classes EVERY DAY. its crazy. i only have 24 hours a day and how to do all these? its really crap. just because i am new, they dump all kinds of unthinkable duties on me and i tell you, i lost weight and almost became crazy. my normal school hours are from 7.30am to around 9pm at night. I stayed in school late every day cause i can't finish my work. i even came back on sundays just to catch up on my marking. and even then, with 8 classes, how to finish? i am not a robot and i need rest, i need to relax. with that kind of workload, i suffered A LOT.

Unless i worked smart (by playing politics), maybe i can get around the system. But i guess i was just a hard-worker that i just tried to cope. The stupid thing was, my confirmation is subjected to only classroom observation. so all those hard work that i put in in other things is not counted lah. if i don't do, i get a bad remark. if i do, i can't seem to manage my basic work. so i tried to juggle. On top of that, one of my colleagues was backstabbing me cause i trusted him. and this made it worse for me. until at last, my P refused to confirm me. i almost wanted to quit and pay back my bond, but i don't know where to get the money from. so i decided to leave that school and was posted to another school in the same zone. Thanks be to God, this school is wayyyy better and i am so happy here. the management and the Principal who confirmed me are really people with a heart. i am so thankful and happy to be in this working environment. and i have completed the bond finally!

And another complaint i have of the school are the students. every morning, the school compound will be filled with cars. somehow, students here are pretty rich (but not so smart, and spoilt). i was given 2 2NA classes who are so rude and foul-mouthed that hearing the word c**&% and all those vulgarities is very commonplace. my lessons are spent just trying to manage the class. the discipline master is not effective and i don't see students changed even after i sent them to the department. i tell you, during the first 3 to 4 mths, i went to the toilet and cried after my lessons with them ended.

cause it hurts so much to hear students hurlting vulgarities at you when all you wanted to do was to share your knowledge with them. that there isnt even an ounce of appreciation for all the things that you've done for them. preparing lessons and all. when all i get at the end of the day is not a 'thank you' but a f*** u, k***** and c****. i even have students throwing chairs at me. i don't know where these creatures come from. back then, i truly regretted joining teaching. moulding the future of the nation? its not MY JOB! its the parent's job, not the maid or even the grandparents'. Its no use providing these 'creatures' with all the comforts (big cars and all) when the parents don't even teach them what basic manners is. and they want to blame the teachers for their child's red marks. goodness...i almost gave up on our society. and i myself am scared to raise a child in this type of environment. I was truly jaded. my noble intention has been jaded by the harsh reality of working life.

Anyway, the reason that i was NOT confirmed was because 'YOU DON'T HAVE GOOD CLASS MANAGEMENT'. GOODNESS!! WHAT IS THAT SUPPOSED TO MEAN? WHY DON'T YOU SHOW ME THROUGH EXAMPLE, MR PRINCIPAL. NOT THROUGH OBSERVATION. in fact, i see experienced teachers having problems with the same kids that i have problems with. come on, teaching is a life-long skill, its not an overnight thing. how can you measure a young, inexperienced teacher against a much older and experienced one? What kind of assessment is that? I truly hated the management of the school, not to mention the politics and students there.

  Evil Bunny:
"my noble intention has been jaded by the harsh reality of working life." Harsh reality of working life IN SINGAPORE to be exact!
  streaming, ways to deal with NormTech kids
Miss Ouch:

I know you may have heard or read this so many times, but thank you for "Punish to Purify" teacher's edition. I was going through a really tough time in my new school, a very notorious one in the East side and your animation was the only thing that made me smile and laugh for the first time
in weeks. I find your articles regarding moe and teachers are things that are lingering at our lips but not spoken. Thank you for making the "rest" understand the position we are in.

Two things to share if you can spare the time, that is with the new project at hand, i'm sure you are super busy and tired.

First, the streaming, whilst i understand that you are so against that, it does makes sense. In my current school, i am surprised to find that even in Sec 2, the Tech students are what we call "illiterate".

Without streaming, it's tough for them to catch up with the "faster" students and they would resent being in school as they see no point in studying as other students are always doing better. And the "faster" students are set back because classes will be at a much slower pace and they in turn will be restless and resent being classmates with the "slower" ones.

These "slow/monkeys/ADHD/rude" students need a different approach to studying, as they have VERY SHORT ATTENTION SPAN, they response to visuals, anything they can do with their hands and anything that moves sooo much better than the "faster" students. That's why, maybe, the goverment came up with streaming. To cater to diverse needs. (Now where have i heard this before?)

Second thing is, from my short experience and observations, these "slow/monkeys/ADHD/rude" students actually response SOOO much better when we treat them like an adult and lay down our simple and clear expectations that they can do.

Example, the very basic and "born with it" RESPECT for the other person. Rationale with them the meaning and how respects work, don't make it all about how they should respect the teacher, rather how it's a 2 way street. When the don't see you so much as a figure of ABSOLUTE AUTHORITY, they soften and are able to compromise better.

TALKING AND RATIONALISING is what get these students to behave. And when this approach fails, then turn to "monster" mode but still rationale and give them the option. They will soften and behave. All the things that i said have been "tested and approved" (but with alot of trial and errorrs) to work with students who are really a nightmare and the cause of all stress and depression in teachers.

All they want to know is that you care for them, and will go to great lengths to help them to learn. Don't need to wreck your brain over it, just compromise, and do activities that you know they can do and is fun. Heck with what the syllabus says, do what you think is the best way the students can learn.

Don't be surprise, they WANT TO LEARN, it's just that when they don't understand, instead of saying they don't get it, their inflated egos get in the way, and they just act up, and soon, everyone follows.

I've been in my new school for 3 weeks, together with my classmate from NIE, and this method works for us, especially her, as she have the Tech classes. And i swear, i see a 360 degree change in them. They are POLITE, WON'T DISRUPT lessons, EAGER to LEARN and showcase an OVER-ALL BETTER ATTITUDE.

I know this is sooo long, but just my 2 cents worth. Keep up the great work, and with the effort, sincerity and this selfless things you do, i THANK YOU for this noble deed. You have made thousands if not more people happy when they are at their lowest or just plain bored =p

The very least i can do, is to pray for your health, better opportunities that PAYS $$$ and your passion to never die. Take care and all the best with your new project!

  "These "slow/monkeys/ADHD/rude" students need a different approach to studying, as they have VERY SHORT ATTENTION SPAN, they response to visuals, anything they can do with their hands and anything that moves sooo much better than the "faster" students. That's why, maybe, the goverment came up with streaming. To cater to diverse needs."

Although I understand that it is practical to set up different classes to cater to special students with special needs like a kid suffering from dyslexia or attention span problems, discipline problem; micromanaging and splitting up the kids into different levels of Normal, Express, NormTech streams have NO SIGNIFICANT BENEFIT. And more importantly, streaming did not proved ANY significant results.

I can say that the MAJOR BULK of our University students (the supposedly the best of what the education system have to offer) are working with the GOVERNMENT right now. Even though they have gone through the current administration style of education system, they are INCAPABLE in creating world recognise brand names like Yamaha, Google, EA Games etc. Do explain to me why this is so apparent cause I have yet to find a reason. Another thing is, those who support streaming are cultivating a culture of arrogance and thus DOES MORE HARM THAN GOOD in the long run.

"
TALKING AND RATIONALISING is what get these students to behave." << Of course that would be the 1st approach for EVERYTHING. But you fail to mention is that this approach is not the ultimate solution for all destruptive T classes. Whats the alternative for students who won't budge with talking, rationalising and countless "reflections"? That is the point of the 3 part article I wrote. From having a discipline team to straight expulsions.. thats my take for students who refuse to conform.

Or let me explain in diagram form on what I mean:


A - A place for the extraordinary brightest. Remember that Malay girl who broke the PSLE record? If she does well on her Secondary education, she will land here.

B - A place for most of us. You and me will be place here. All kids from Normal to Express will be mixed and divided into classes. No micromanaging here. Just beneficial knowledge at a comfortable pace.

C - A place for students who have attention span problems, destructive, etc. They are not dumb, they need constant supervision. Teachers at this school are of a different breed and they are given higher pay than B.

 
 
happeepill.com Copyright © | All Rights Reserved